Forge Idea: let Speclr challenge your idea
For Discovery: when Forge Idea becomes available, how the session with an unconvinced investor runs, what it can and cannot change in your Vision Statement, and how to end it and run it again.
Updated
Why argue with your own idea
- Completeness is not convictionThe completeness score says how much is filled in. Forge Idea tests whether it holds up against someone who does not want to believe it.
- The worst gap firstEach turn goes to the most serious weakness across the whole statement, not to the next empty section.
- A clear verdictWhen you defend a point well, Speclr says so before it moves on.
Build enough to argue with
Forge Idea is offered in Discovery only, beside the three modes above the chat input. Until at least four of the eight Vision sections have content, it stays greyed out and its tooltip reads "There is not enough in the Vision Statement yet to challenge. Build it out first."
Once enough is there, the tooltip reads "I challenge what stands, the way an investor who is not yet convinced would."
Start the session
Click "Forge Idea", or ask for it in the chat while no session runs. Speclr shows "Reviewing the Vision Statement" and "Preparing the first challenge", then opens with one sentence that marks the change of tone and a single, direct objection. It does not warm up: the first challenge already goes to the weakest point it sees.
Answer the investor
Reply as you would in a pitch: defend the point, bring evidence, or concede and improve it. A vague or circular answer is pressed further on the same point. Expect questions such as:
- Is the problem urgent, or a nice-to-have? Why now?
- Is the target group specific enough to exclude someone?
- Who exactly pays, and what do they give up by not paying?
- Could your success metrics prove the vision wrong?
Speclr writes in the language you write in.
End it and come back
"End session" in the chat input ends Forge Idea like any other session: Speclr sums up what it established and the phase returns to Idle Mode. See Choose how to work: Interactive, Pre Fill, Auto.
Forge Idea is offered again straight away. Revise the statement, then let it challenge you again. In the chat, a thin line named "Forge Idea" marks where each such session began.
What it changes
Forge Idea can rewrite a Vision section, but only when the conversation has arrived at a stronger wording that you gave. It never writes something you have not said. A changed section is assessed again, as after any change.
What it looks at
The Vision Statement, the idea you started with and your project's Constitution. It leaves out your project's Context and the story map: an investor challenges the pitch, not your internal notes.
Before you finish Discovery
When Speclr suggests finishing Discovery, it mentions that Forge Idea is available. Running it is up to you; it is not required. See Finish a phase.
